Skillful Giving
Is giving soap to villagers in India a thoughtless act? But is it okay to hand out money to adult beggars? By leaving sweets am I actually helping create more cavities in a child’s teeth? Instead of candy, how about giving meat? Eating meat is usually considered a luxury in villages and deprived communities. But villagers don’t really need anything physical from us. It is sometimes more of an insult to assume that they need things like soap which we normally see as useful and desirable. On the other hand, it seems right to leave warm woolen socks to your trekking guide, with whom you spent time and got to know. So what is right and what is wrong?
Image 2 : School kids near Luang Prabang, Laos. At this encounter, I had taught them all how to make paper airplanes. I always look back at that moment, wishing I could’ve done something more substantial with them.
It is virtually always irresponsible to give gifts to the unaccompanied children of strangers - whether you’re in a remote Cambodian village or even in the streets of New York. We have no way of verifying that the parents or guardians of these kids approve of the gifts or of the begging, and we have no right to interfere with their discipline just to create a feel-good moment. It seems like a good compromise to give pens and pencils, but it makes more sense to donate these supplies to schools rather than kids on the street.
As a guest, however, giving gifts is important. It helps offset the host’s cost of putting you up. Costs are considerable, especially when thinking about food. Giving to the owner of a house you are staying in seems appropriate, even if you are paying, especially if your gift is food. Local handicrafts are also a good way to spread your largess, and invest in a sustainable cause when visiting a foreign community.
It is the arbitrary flinging coins that bothers me, although even the non-arbitrary charity methods can also cause many problems. The outpouring of donations after the 2004 tsunami resulted in an immense amount of clothing donations, much in excess of what locals could ever use, in addition to other fabrics inappropriate for any local season. So what? Well, locals were concerned that accumulation of water in the heaps of clothing, especially in the rainy season, could lead to breeding of mosquitoes and the growth of mold. If this happened, malaria and other health concerns, on top of the problems already caused by the tsunami, would add to the already existing multitude of worries.
The emphasis for volunteer work in developing countries is to empower and hire local people, when possible, to address local issues, build their own capacities and provide them with employment opportunities. The priority should be to fill gaps in local knowledge and skills and not to give the foreign volunteer an outlet for a seemingly special excursion in the third world. It is much more beneficial for them to hire local people to paint walls, dig ditches and build houses, when compared to bringing a foreign volunteer.
“That said, the days of international volunteers are not numbered. There will always be a need for international volunteers, either to fill gaps in knowledge and service in a local situation, or because a more neutral observer/contributor is required. So, to volunteer overseas, you need to have skills and experience that are critically needed in a particular region, and that can be utilized by local institutions and local people quickly.”[5]
Xenophilia and Responsible Travel
Ethan Zuckerman[6] writes on Global Souls and xenophilia, which is defined as the attraction to foreign peoples, cultures, or customs. He argues that isolationist nationalism holds grave economically suicidal circumstances in this increasingly globalized world. Global Souls, as he describes, are best placed to create solutions to global problems, to invent new products for global markets and to build bridges and understanding between different nations.
I strongly believe in the promise that these so called Global Souls, or world-travelers, hold for the better future of our society. Travel is a way to extend beyond cultural boundaries and gaps, by creating person to person relationships, which are strong and long-lasting. More and more people engage in the act of travel, specifically to developing and third world locations. However, with travel also comes responsibility.
Pico Iyer, a well know travel writer, once said: “travel for me is an act of discovery and of responsibility as well as a grand adventure and a constant liberation.” A major reason to engage in travel is to get out from behind our desks and into the world; to learn about the things we wish to understand, change, or somehow influence. Regardless of how far we physically travel, the inevitable base of these journeys incorporates cross-cultural communication.
As tourists we may visit a certain community only once in our lifetimes, but our experiences and memories stay with us forever. Responsible travel is a term I’ve seen frequently in the past few months. By traveling responsibly, one aims to be sensitive and aware about local culture and ecology. Tourism is the largest economic sector in terms of earnings worldwide,[7] certainly playing a large role in third world economies. But the masses of visitors are harming and changing these exotic, once untouched parts of the world, taking away the very essence of what draws tourists there initially. However, it is often forgotten that tourism and this very process of cross-cultural communication can actually be an incentive for creation. In places like Bali, the influx of tourists has generated new dances, new musical forms, and breathed new forms of life into a culture that they took for granted.
Zaid Hassan[8] claims that “ the invitation ” is probably the most indispensable tool we have when we visit indigenous populations around the world. When no invitation exists from local entities, inter-cultural encounters can potentially deepen the gap between locals and foreigners, especially when ignorant travelers disrespect important customs. Many communities value their privacy and prefer not to engage with uninvited strangers. When interested in a specific community, it might be a good idea to invite its members into one’s own community - maybe for a cup of coffee. Developing sensitivity toward the invitation is critical in building healthy relationships across traditional cultures.
Tourism and Travel
Every person travels for a different purpose. While some just long for an exotic vacation on a white sand beach, many long for a more culturally exciting learning experience. Pico Iyer writes about reasons for travel:
“I think the main reason I travel, if I were to sum it up in one word, is for ambiguity . The reason I love travel is not just because it transports you in every sense, but because it confronts you with emotional and moral challenges that you would never have to confront at home. So I like going out in search of moral and emotional adventure which throws me back upon myself and forces me to reconsider my assumptions and the things I took for granted. It sends me back a different person.”
International tourism is an important potential growth sector for many countries. In a research done by the World Bank, it is stated that there are over 300 million foreign arrivals per year in developing countries. Extracting the expatriates and those who travel for business purposes from this figure, it is possible to assume that the actual number of tourists is still in the high tens of millions.
There are a number of common problems that have been linked to Third World tourism, which call into question its usefulness as a component of development strategies. These include foreign domination and dependency and loss of identity among host communities.
With increasing frequency, international tourism is being grouped together in the development literature with other major new “growth sectors” that are believed to show much promise for stimulating rapid growth based on the comparative advantages of Third World countries.
In his study[9], John Brohman claims that market forces by themselves, especially within highly polarized communities, are incapable of resolving issues related to either long-term sustainability or the distribution of costs and benefits generated by tourism. However, he suggests that an emphasis should be placed on the design of alternative tourism strategies that call for increased community participation.
Over the past two decades, the concept of alternative tourism has emerged as one of the most widely used and abused phrases in the tourism literature, representing any form of travel different from conventional mass tourism.
However, many believe that tourism bears a nearly direct lineage to the first manifestation of the first/third world dynamic globalization: colonialism. This is most obvious in the fact that nearly all tourists come from the first world, notably Europe and the United States, and are also the primary owners of the tourist infrastructure. Tourism, like colonialism, involves an occupation and domination of space, in this instance by the tourist structure and tourists themselves. It is also an industry that, like colonialism, is enabled by expansions of power. Third world tourism can be seen as a continuation and a perpetuation of the colonial legacy, providing enjoyable exploration for tourists along with exploitation for locals.
Sustainable (eco) Tourism
Sustainable tourism is a practice which attempts to make a low impact on the environment and local culture, while helping to generate income, employment, and the conservation of local ecosystems. It is responsible tourism, both ecologically and culturally sensitive. Internationally, tourism is the largest economic sector in terms of earnings, and in terms of number of people employed.[10]
Ecotourism aims to conserve the environment and to improve the well-being of communities, by sponsoring responsible travel to natural areas. This type of travel minimizes the impact on a community’s environment by practicing cultural awareness and respect, while contributing financially to conservation and to local people.
Eco-tourism is a method for preserving and sustaining the diversity of the world’s natural and cultural environments. It accommodates and entertains visitors in a way that is minimally intrusive or destructive to the environment and supports the native cultures in the locations it operates in. A responsible traveler is the genuine outcome of eco-tourism. Its basic rule is to seek out and support locally owned businesses, and to ensure maximum community and conservation benefits from tourist spending.
The term Geotourism is closely related, but is concerned instead with preserving a destination’s geographic character—the entire combination of natural and human attributes that make one place distinct from another. Geotourism encompasses both cultural and environmental concerns regarding travel, as well as the local impact tourism has upon communities and their individual economies and lifestyles.
ST-EP Initiative (United Nations)
For many developing countries, tourism is a primary source of income and helps a major part of the population make a living. The United Nation's World Tourism Organization launched the ST-EP initiative back in 2002, aimed at creatively developing sustainable tourism as a force for poverty elimination.
Pro-Poor Tourism
Poverty tourism, also sometimes known as poorism, is defined as travel that includes tours of or accommodations in slums or dangerous urban neighborhoods. One of the starting venues to hold these types of tours was Rio de Janeiro, where tour operators have been escorting foreign visitors throughout the city’s infamous favelas.
Reality Tours & Travel[11], a company situated in Mumbai, India, takes visitors on walking tours of Mumbai’s largest slum, Dharavi. They pledge that once the company starts to make a profit, it will donate 80 percent of its earnings to a charitable group that works in Dharavi. The company has a no-photography policy, to keep the tours from becoming too intrusive. For the same reason they keep each group limited to five people. They claim that they show a “positive side of the slum”. Salam Balak Trust works with street children in New Delhi, charging visitors $4.50 for a 2-hour tour of the Delhi slums and railway station.
There is still a substantial public argument regarding this new sort of tourism. Critics call it “exploration by voyeuristic travelers” while defenders say they are only trying to educate western tourists to the plight of the poor. Some claim that it is disrespectful to “cash in on poverty”, or that it treats human beings like animals. Reality Tours & Travel have yet to prove their worth. As they are becoming more popular, they are very careful with regards to reporting all their monthly expenses and profits.
Voluntourism
Voluntourism allows foreign visitors to pay for the opportunity to physically work for a local cause in developing nations. A proliferating number of companies and organizations are sending travelers to do volunteer work abroad. Cross Cultural Solutions sends volunteers to countries like China and Guatemala, where they work for orphanages, schools and hospitals.
Ina survey on travelers within the ITP community, over 90% of the participants stated that they carried some sort of guilt from traveling, as well as a wished to have been able to give back something to their hosting communities while traveling. Many travelers do want to make a difference and help out, if they can. A big problem lies in the fact that volunteering while traveling is not easy to organize. The sheer logistics of finding the right information can be time consuming. It is usually necessary to pay a large sum of money to the organization in charge, and it can take you far out of your way, losing valuable travel time.
volunteeradventures.com state that their mission is to create and promote volunteer opportunities that improve local lives and the environment by connection between worthy local projects with volunteers around the world. Using their website, it is possible to order a “meaningful spring break” in Guatemala for the price of 995$ per week. It includes lodging and meals, but still extremely expensive, when compared to the cost of living in Guatemala.
Earthwatch and Habitat for Humanity are also a popular voluntourism option.
stepuptravel.org
This is an existing “craigslist”-style service for the responsible traveler. The website highlights posts from different services worldwide, concentrating on helping make the smaller, private businesses seen, and help them make a better profit by advertising their service within the traveler community. Most existing posts describe hotels, guest houses and other places to stay while traveling. The “collaborative projects” part of the site describes possible volunteering opportunities, and provides the following categories: Democracy, Economic Dev, Education, Environment, Gender, Equality, Health, Human Rights and Technology.
Alternative Tourism
Alternative tourism is thought to consist of smaller-scale, dispersed, low-density developments. Often, these developments are located in and organized by villages or communities, where it is hoped they will foster more meaningful interaction between tourists and local residents, as well as be less socially and culturally disruptive than resorts. By placing an emphasis on smaller-scale, local ownership, it is hoped that this type of tourism can spread its effects within the host community, and avoid problems of excessive foreign exchange leakages.
Another aspect of alternative tourism is encouraging community participation in local/regional planning. By allowing for local participation in decision making, it is expected that more appropriate forms of tourism development will be established that will be viewed positively by local residents. Alternative tourism emphasized sustainability in both an environmental and cultural sense. This type of tourism encourages sensitivity and respect for cultural traditions by creating opportunities for education and cultural exchange through interpersonal dialogue and organized encounters.
In the short term, alternative tourism cannot realistically be expected to replace mass tourism in most Third World countries. Nevertheless, it can complement mass tourism in various ways, as well as provide ideas and methods by which mass tourism might be reformed to more resemble an alternative strategy. Alternative tourism strategies ought to be designed to provide more appropriate forms of development that reduce the negative impacts and increase the positive effects of tourism. These include a stress on small-scale, locally owned developments that spread effects, greater community participation in tourism planning, and more attention for the cultural and environmental sustainability of tourism projects.
Research Conclusions
I strongly believe that by taking advantage of technology, these opportunities can be made in a more inexpensive manner. There exists a cultural gap, and an intermediary is usually necessary to bridge between both sides. I have never taken part in these so called slum tours. While traveling, I visited many of the slum areas by myself. I think that ‘seeing is believing’, and that by seeing, one’s perspective is transformed. This is may have an impact later on, and that is the importance of travel.
[5] writes Jayne Cravens, on her site: http://www.coyotecommunications.com
[6]http://www.ethanzuckerman.com/blog/?p=1371
[7] Statistics from studies completed by the United Nations World Tourism Organization
[8] His work can be seen at: http://www.worldchanging.com/bios/zaid.html
[9] Item #7 in the bibliography
[10] As claimed by the Global Development Research Center (GDRC) on their website: http://www.gdrc.org/
[11] Their website can be found here: http://realitytoursandtravel.com



